CISG Advisory Council Opinion No. 9

Consequences of Avoidance of the Contract

ADDENDUM: CASES CITED

Austria 

Oberster Gerichtshof, 10 March 1998. Note 28
Oberster Gerichtshof 19 January 1999 (Coat hanger case). Note 8
Oberster Gerichtshof 29 June 1999 (Wall panels case). Notes 17, 19, 43

Belgium

Hof van Beroep Gent 11 September 2003 (Digital archive case). Note 71

China

China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission

- Polyethylene film case of 10 March 1995. Notes 34 and 75
- Automobile case of 23 April 1997. Note 59
- Glassware case of 30 November 1998. Note 71

Finland

Käräjäoikeus Kuopio 5 November 1996 (Butter case). Note 74

France

Cour de cassation 26 May 1999 (Karl Schreiber v Thermo Dynamique). Note 65
Cour d'appel de Paris 6 April 1995 (Thyssen Stahlunion v Maaden). Note 72
Cour d'appel de Paris 14 January 1998 (Société Productions v Roberto Faggioni). Note 43
Cour d'appel de Aix-en-Provence 21 November 1996 (Karl Schreiber v Thermo Dynamique). Note 65

Germany

Bundesgerichtshof 25 June 1997 (Stainless steel wire case). Note 7
Oberlandesgericht Celle 24 May 1995 (Used printing press case). Note 69
Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf 2 July 1993 (Veneer cutting machine case). Note 48
Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf 28 May 2004 (TV sets case). Notes 22, 70
Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt 17 September 1991 (Shoes case). Note 7
Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt 18 January 1994 (Shoes case). Note 69
Oberlandesgericht Hamburg 26 November 1999 (Jeans case). Note 63
Oberlandesgericht Karlsruhe 19 December 2002 (Machine case). Note 69
Oberlandesgericht Köln 14 October 2002 (Designer clothes case). Note 63
Oberlandesgericht München 8 February 1995. Note 69
Oberlandesgericht München 28 January 1998 (Automobiles case). Note 30.
Oberlandesgericht München 19 October 2006 (Auto case). Note 22
Oberlandesgericht Oldenburg 1 February 1995. Note 80
Landgericht Düsseldorf 11 October 1995 (Generator case). Note 27
Landgericht Freiburg 22 August 2002 (Automobile case). Notes 41, 81
Landgericht Giessen 17 December 2002 (Vehicle safety device case). Note 48
Landgericht Krefeld 24 November 1992 (Shoes case). Notes 32, 45
Landgericht Landshut 5 April 1995 (Sport clothing case). Notes 69, 70
Landgericht Mönchengladbach 15 July 2003 (Filters case). Note 63
Landgericht München 20 March 1995 (Frozen bacon case). Note 62
Schiedsgericht Hamburger Freundschaftliche Arbitrage 29 December 1998 (Cheese case). Note 71

ICC Court of Arbitration

Award No 7585 of 1992 (Foamed board machinery case). Note 73
Award No 6653 of 26 March 1993 (Steel bars case). Notes 66, 72
Award No 7660 of 23 August 1994 (Battery machinery case). Note 69
Award No 9978 of March 1999. Notes 15, 30, 69
Award No 9887 of August 1999 (Chemicals case). Note 15

Italy

Pretura circondariale Parma 24 November 1989 (Foliopack v Daniplast). Note 76

Mexico

Compromex Arbitration 4 May 1993 (José Luis Morales v Nez Marketing). Note 82

Russian Federation

Tribunal of International Commercial Arbitration at the Russian Federation Chamber of Commerce and Industry

- Case No 1/1993 of 15 April 1994. Notes 71, 76
- Case No 161/1994 of 25 April 1995. Note 14
- Case No 2/1997 of 11 May 1995. Note 36
- Case No 22/1995 of 1 December 1995. Note 74
- Case No 133/1994 of 19 December 1995. Note 71
- Case No 72/1995 of 25 April 1996. Note 74
- Case No 82/1996 of 3 March 1997. Notes 19, 22
- Case No 439/1995 of 29 May 1997. Note 74
- Case No 53/1997 of 25 December 1997. Note 74
- Case No 160/1997 of 5 March 1998. Note 15
- Case No 280/1999 of 13 June 2000. Notes 13, 15, 16
- Case No 99/2002 of 16 April 2003. Note 71
- Case No 135/2002 of 16 June 2003. Note 64
- Case No 100/2002 of 19 May 2004. Notes 71, 77
- Case No 175/2003 of 28 May 2004. Note 69
- Case No 95/2004 of 27 May 2005. Note 15

Spain

Juzgado de primera instancia Tudela 29 March 2005 (Bricks case). Note 74

Switzerland

Bundesgerichtshof 20 December 2006 (Machines case). Note 62
Tribunale d'apello Lugano/Ticino 15 January 1998 (Cocoa beans case). Note 69
Kantonsgericht Schaffhausen 27 January 2004 (Model locomotives case). Notes 40, 69
Kanstonsgericht Valais 21 February 2005 (CNC machine case). Note 45
Handelsgericht St. Gallen 3 December 2002 (Sizing machine case). Note 27
Handelsgerich Zürich 5 February 1997 (Sunflower oil case). Notes 66, 70
Bezirksgericht Saane 20 February 1997 (Alkohol Royal Feinsprit liquor case). Notes 7, 59, 69

United States

Federal District Court New York 14 April 1992 (Filanto v Chilewich). Note 13
Federal District Court Illinois 28 March 2002 (Usinor Industeel v Leeco Steel). Note 25