Case law citing the CISG Advisory Council Opinions

Number of case citations

 Total: 29 cases

Op 1

Op 2

Op 3

Op 4

Op 5

Op 6

Op 7

Op 8

Op 9

Op 10

3

3

5

2

3

9

1

 0

2

 0

Op 11

Op 12

Op 13

Op 14

Op 15

Op 16

Op 17

Op 18

Op 19

0

0

29

1

0

2

0

1

 0

 

Arbitral Tribunals

Naftogaz v. Gazprom I (Gas Sales Arbitration) 31 May 2017 Arbitration Institute of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce (SCC)
Opinion No 7
Case text  

Turkish-Indian sales contract case  2018  ICC International Court of Arbitration Geneva (Switzerland)
Opinion No 6
Published 43 Yearbook Commercial Arbitration (Y.B. Com. Arb.) (2018), 184–234

 Industrial plants case  Ad hoc Arbitral Tribunal 17 December 2019
Opinion No 4, No 6 and No 9
Case Abstract

Belgium

 Volz v Groep Jam Hof van Beroep Antwerpen (Court of Appeal Antwerp) Case no 2013-AR/299 of 9 February  2015
Opinion no 13
Case text (Dutch)

Canada

 Hewlett-Packard France v. Matrox Graphics Inc. 10 January 2020 Cour supérieure du Québec/Superior Court of Québec
Opinion No 6
Case text 

Czech Republic

Ideal Bike Corp. v. IMPEXO spol. s r.o. Nejvyšší soud České republiky (Supreme Court of the Czech Republic) 23 Cdo 1308/2011
Opinion No 1
https://cisg-online.org/search-for-cases?caseId=8663 

El Salvador

Las Cascadas Multiservicios SA of CV v Operadora Del Sur, S.A. of C.V.  5 March 2018 Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice Case no 183-CAC-2017  
Opinion No 6
Case text (Spanish)

Germany

Bundesgerichtshof (Supreme Court) 28 May 2014  VIII ZR 410/12 (Bowling alleys case)
Opinion No 13
Case text (German)

Bundesgerichtshof (Supreme Court) 24 September 2014  VIII ZR 394/12 (Hungarian Injection Mould Tools case)
Opinion No 5
Case text (German)

Brewing tanks case 21 December 2015 Oberlandesgericht Stuttgart (Court of Appeal Stuttgart)
Opinion No 13
Case text (German)

Latvia

 Rīgas apgabaltiesa (Court of Appeal Riga) 10 October 2016 C28248415 / CA-2212-16/23
Opinion No 1
Case text (Latvian)

Netherlands

[___] v. Pastificio Della Mamma S.A. 9 March 2010 Gerechtshof [Appellate Court] Arnhem 
Opinion No 2
Case text (Dutch)

Fleck Elektroinstallationen GmbH v. Transquest Tag & Tracing Solutions B.V.  6 November 2013 Rechtbank [District Court] Gelderland
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Kapiteyn BV v Kurt Weiss Greenhouses Inc  8 January 2014 Rechtbank [District Court] Amsterdam
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Feinbäckerei Otten GmbH v Rhumfeld Winter BV  22 April 2014 Gerechtshof [District court] Den Haag
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Armacom EBVBA v Geurts Trucks BV  30 July 2014 Rechtbank [District Court] Gelderland
Opinion no 13
Case text (Dutch)

Trading Company P. van Adrighem B.V. v. Integrated Logistics Co. 26 August 2014 Gerechtshof [Appellate Court] Den Haag
Opinion No 6
Case text (Dutch)

Wavin Overseas BV v Picenum Plast SPA 3 December 2014 Rechtbank [District Court] Overijssel
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Componenta BV v [handelsnaam] GmbH 24 February 2015 Gerechtshof 's-Hertogenbosch (Lagerzapfencase) [Appellate Court]
 Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Countryside SAL v Terrapoint BV   27 May 2015 Rechtbank [District Court] Zeeland-West-Brabant
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

De Nederlandse Organisatie voor Toegepast-natuurwetenschappelijk Onderzoek TNO v Zygolot GmbH  10 June 2015 Rechtbank [District Court] Den Haag
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Silicon Refractory Anchoring Systems BV v Refrattari Sirc SRI  19 August 2015 Rechtbank [District Court] Den Haag
Opinions No 13 and No 16
Case text (Dutch)

Gebrüder GmbH&Co KG [firmanaam] v Machine-en Transportwerktuigenfabriek [vestigingsnaam] BV  (Conveyor belts case) 29 September 2015 Gerechtshof  [Appellate Court]  's-Hertogenbosch
Opinion No 13 
Case text (Dutch)

Antima International BVBA v [gedaagde] 14 October 2015 Rechtbank [District Court] Gelderland
Opinion No 13 
Case text (Dutch)

Integrated Logistics Co v [verweerster] 16 October 2015  Parket bij de Hoge Raad [Supreme Court]
Opinions No 6 and 14
Case text (Dutch)

World Wide Quality in Meat BV v [gedaagde] 20 January 2016 Rechtbank [District Court] Midden-Nederland
Opinion No 13 
Case text (Dutch)

BVBA Food Ingredients Technologies v [X] 23 March 2016 Rechtbank [District Court] Overijssel
Opinion No 13 
Case text (Dutch)

Dibalex BVV v Delta Sjhelving Systems GmbH 29 June 2016 Rechtbank [District Court] Rotterdam
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Cheese case 16 November 2016 Rechtbank Midden-Nederland (District Court Midden-Nederland)
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Potassium peroxide sulphate case 12 April 2017 Rechtbank Limburg (District Court Limburg)
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Flexible plastics case 19 July 2017 Rechtbank Overijssel (District Court Overijssel)
Opinion 13
Case text (Dutch)

Genson BV v S&A Produce Ltd  5 March 2018 Rechtbank  [District Court] Oost-Brabant
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Four Directions Ltd. v. [...] 07 November 2018 Rechtbank Amsterdam (District Court Amsterdam) 
Opinion No 6
Case text (Dutch)

Seilfabrik Ullmann AG v. Lift-Tex Industrie B.V. 5 February 2019  Gerechtshof Arnhem-Leeuwarden (Court of Appeal Arnhem-Leeuwarden)
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Syrmos Levantis S.A. Rotosal v. Twente Trucks 30 July 2019 Rechtbank Overijssel (District Court Overijssel)
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Gemini Corporation N.V. v. 24/7 Media B.V. 11 November 2019 Rechtbank [District Court] Noord-Nederland 
Opinion No 9
Full text (Dutch)

SK Energy Europe Ltd. v. Trefoil Trading B.V. 11 December 2019  Rechtbank Rotterdam (District Court Rotterdam)
Opinion No 13
Case text (Dutch)

Top Mark B.V. v. Orchestra-Prémaman Belgium S.A. 19 December 2019 Rechtbank Midden-Nederland (District Court Midden-Nederland)
Opinion No 13
Case reference (Dutch)

Top Mark B.V. v. Orchestra-Prémaman Belgium S.A. 02 June 2020 Gerechtshof Arnhem-Leeuwarden (Court of Appeal Arnhem-Leeuwarden)
Opinion No 13
Case text (English)

Poland

Spoldzielnia Pracy "A" in N v GmbH & Co. KG in B 11 May 2007 Supreme Court of Poland (Shoe leather case)
Opinion No 5
Case text (Polish)

Car paint case 23 February 2012 Sąd Okręgowy w Olsztynie (District Court Olsztyn)
Opinion No 5
Case text(Polish)

Slovak Republic

Green Best Sp. z o.o. Sp.k. v. 4 Fruit, spol. s r.o. 11 June 2015 Okresný súd Dunajská Streda (District Court Dunajska Streda) 
Opinion No 2
Case text (Slovak)

Coplass di Gianni Cortini e C. S.a.s. v. Rudos Ružomberok s.r.o. 30 May 2018 Krajský súd v Žiline (Regional Court Zilina)
Opinion No 4 and 6
Case text (Slovak)

Slovenia

 Steatite grinding balls case 29 February 2016 Okrožno sodišče v Ljubljani (District Court Ljubljana)
Opinion No 13
Case text (Slovenian)

Switzerland

Electronic electricity meters case  28 May 2019 Bundesgericht (Federal Supreme Court) Case no  4A_543/2018 28 May 2019
Opinion 16
Case text (German)

United States of America

 Delizia v. Columbia Distributing Company, 9 September 2004 Federal District Court [State of Washington]
Opinions No 1 and No 2
Case text (English)

TeeVee Tunes, Inc. v. Gerhard Schubert GmbH, 23 August 2006, Federal Court [Southern District of New York]
Opinion No 3
Case text (English)

Alpha Prime Development Corporation, Plaintiff, v. Holland Loader 6 July 2010 District Court [Colorado]
Opinion No  3
Case text (English)

Bodum USA, Inc. v. La Cafetiere, Inc., 2 September 2010, Federal Appellate Court [5th Circuit]
Opinion No 3
Case text (English)

Cedar Petrochemicals inc. v. Dongbu Hannong Chemical Ltd  28 September 2011 Federal District Court [New York]
Opinion No 3
Case text (English)

Nucap Industries Inc. et al v Robert Bosch LLC et al 29 August 2016 District Court [Northern District of Illinois Eastern Division]
Opinion No 13

Nucap Industries Inc. et al v Robert Bosch LLC et al 31 March 2017 District Court [Northern District of Illinois]
Opinion No 13
Case text

Nucap Industries Inc. et al v Robert Bosch LLC et al 
Case text

Sunrise Foods international Inc v Ryan Hinton Inc 2019 WL 3755499 (D Idaho, 2019)
Opinion No 6

HRC-Hainan Holding Company, LLC v. Yihan Hu 2020 WL 906719 (ND Cal, 2020)
Opinion No 3
Case text (English)